JCPC/2026/0088
•
TORT
David John Humbles and others (Respondents) v Matthew Wickers and others (Appellants) (Isle of Man)
Contents
Case summary
Case ID
JCPC/2026/0088
Jurisdiction
Isle of Man
Parties
Appellant(s)
(1) Matthew Wickers, (2) Dennis Lavin, (3) John Tinsley
Respondent(s)
(1) David John Humbles, (2) Michael Ross Riddell, (3) Guy Austin Wiltcher
Issue
Should the directors of companies involved in a failed property development scheme be held liable to the investors in any of fraudulent misrepresentation, unlawful distribution, or fraudulent breach of fiduciary duty?
Facts
This appeal concerns failed investments in the development of property overlooking Regent’s Park in central London. The Appellants were investors in the project. The Respondents were directors of various companies involved in the project: Oakmayne Properties (Regeneration) Limited (“OPR”); Falmouth Limited (“Falmouth”); and Falmouth Developments Limited (“FDL”). A brochure inviting investment in the project was provided to each of the Appellants prior to their respective decisions to invest. The brochure did not disclose that a success fee was to be paid by FDL to OPR on acquisition of the property. The development project ultimately made a loss, and the Appellants lost most of the money they had invested. Falmouth and FDL were placed into liquidation in 2014. The liquidators’ claims against the Respondents were assigned to the Appellants. In their personal capacity as investors, the Appellants allege that the Respondents made fraudulent misrepresentations in the brochure. In the claims which they have been assigned, the Appellants seek the amount of the success fee on the basis that it was an unlawful distribution of profits, and the Respondents committed a fraudulent breach of fiduciary duty by paying it. The Appellants were successful before the Isle of Man High Court, but the Respondents’ appeal to the Staff of Government (Appeal) Division succeeded. The Appellants now appeal to the Privy Council.
Date of issue
9 October 2026
Case origin
PTA